The Illusion of Truth

“The Big Lie” is a propaganda technique in which an outrageous falsehood is repeated constantly until the public accepts it as truth. The premise is that since no one would presume to invent such a massive lie, it must be true. Of course, people like Nazi propaganda minister, Joseph Goebbels, and other more recent politicians, succeed because people fall for that deceptive premise. In fact, these evil people DO invent massive, outrageous lies in order to manipulate people.

Familiarity

Psychological research shows why the Big Lie technique works. They call it the “Illusory Truth Effect.” The effect is that people tend to believe false information to be true after repeated exposure. This is because the brain has a cognitive bias called “fluency” that processes familiar information more easily. Because repeated statements are more familiar, they feel more true. Essentially, familiarity is mistaken for credibility.

A related factor is “source amnesia.” People often forget where they heard information, they tend to remember only that it feels familiar. Also, of course, if a piece of false information serves to reinforce a person’s fears, biases, opinions, and/or political identity, it will be quickly believed since it reaffirms ones existing self image.

Repetition

This aspect of human psychology has serious real-world implications. The advertising world has long understood the value of memorable slogans and repetitive product claims to build brand loyalty. Political campaigns also use repetitive slogans. The campaigns that have the most money to spread their “message” usually win – regardless of the truthfulness of their message.

The widepread adoption of social media has made this problem dramatically worse. These platforms are literally information repeating machines and have absolutely no incentive to filter out lies. In fact, because lies spread more rapidly than truth, the platforms actually have a financial incentive to spread lies.

Sadly, the illusory truth effect effect can also dull people’s moral sense. Repeated exposure to news about wrongdoing can, through familiarity, make an immoral or illegal act seem less unethical over time.

Strategies that can help

Clearly, if one wishes to live a life of truth and integrity, you must develop a set of strategies and develop practical skills to help you avoid deception. Here are some suggestions:

Prebunking (innoculation): Learn as much as you can about propaganda techniques and logical fallacies. This will help you be less susceptable to manipulation when you encounter them in the real world.

Accuracy Focus: Determining the accuracy of information at the first point of contact can help protect you against the effect of later repetitions.

Pause and Verify: Slow down and look for evidence that supports the claims you hear. Consider the reliability of the source. Don’t just believe everything you hear – especially online!


Sources:
— “Illusory Truth Effect,” Psychology Today (online).
— “Illusory Truth Effect,” Wikipedia.

4 thoughts on “The Illusion of Truth”

  1. We LDS remain vulnerable to these techniques because our Church owned Deseret News does nothing to counter them. Sad but true. We are in desperate shape.

  2. Trump has established understandings with a variety of interests – corporate, technical (Silicon Valley) and religious. These go like this – Trump agrees to avoid going after them, while they agree not to go after Trump in a major way. This setup is increasingly common with media. They are easier and easier on Trump (includes Deseret News). In religion we have the evangelicals like Franklin Graham. To his great credit this DOES NOT include Pope Leo.

    Do the Church and the Deseret News have an understanding with Trump? Such is the only way I can account for the kid glove treatment of Trump by the D News.

Comments are closed.